Java Man and the Colonial Legacy of Fossil Collections

C.A. Drieënhuizen, Fenneke Sysling

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperAcademic

Abstract

This paper looks at human fossil collections in the Netherlands that were excavated in Dutch colonial Indonesia in 1891-92. The most famous specimen is what came to be called Java Man: the skullcap of a homo erectus. It was found on the island of Java by a team led by Dutch palaeontologist Eugène Dubois, who took his finds to the Netherlands where they ended up in the Natural History Museum in Leiden. Other notable finds of early hominids in the Dutch colonies include those excavated in the 1930s on Java by G.H.R. von Koenigswald.
Java man is one of the highlights of the Natural History Museum in Leiden. Although in the Netherlands, like in other countries, cultural objects and physical anthropology collections have been the subject of debate in recent years, Java Man and the other human fossil collections (part of which are now in the Senckenberg Institute in Frankfurt, Germany) have not been part of these discussions.
This is surprising given the fact that Java Man in particular is a single, well-known object and, as we show in this paper, the fossil collections have been claimed by Indonesia several times in the past. Already in 1951, Indonesia – independent for 2 years - first specified restitution claims which included collections of fossilized human skulls. For Indonesia, these fossils were important because they were useful in the new national narrative of the Indonesian state. They were proof that Indonesia was one of the oldest inhabited islands in the world and perhaps a cradle of mankind. The fossils referred to a pre-colonial past that could be read as something that all Indonesians shared.
The exodus of the objects, according to Indonesian politician Mohammad Yamin, symbolized scientific imperialism and harmed Indonesia’s scientific interests. Around fifteen years after the first request, Indonesian scientists such as palaeontologist Teuku Jacob continued to call for the return of the paleontological collections. Only a few objects returned informally.
With our focus on these objects’ provenance, their long contested political ownership and their representation in the Netherlands and in Indonesia, we emphasize that fossilized remains are sites of contested histories, identities and desire. We problematize histories of collecting and knowledge that emerged in Europe, to undo what Mignolo calls the coloniality of knowledge. We also suggest that Natural History Museums should be praised if they take the initiative to re-inscribe histories and perspectives in order to provide an active space for decolonial dialogues.
Original languageEnglish
Number of pages7
Publication statusPublished - 2018
EventPolitics of Natural History, or: How to Decolonize the Natural History Museum - Berlin, Berlin, Germany
Duration: 6 Sep 20187 Sep 2018

Conference

ConferencePolitics of Natural History, or: How to Decolonize the Natural History Museum
CountryGermany
CityBerlin
Period6/09/187/09/18

Fingerprint

Indonesia
Fossil
Colonies
Java
The Netherlands
Natural History Museum
History
Leiden
Exodus
Cradle
Early Hominids
Politicians
Germany
Restitution
Ownership
1930s
Homo Erectus
Imperialism
National Narrative
Skull

Cite this

Drieënhuizen, C. A., & Sysling, F. (2018). Java Man and the Colonial Legacy of Fossil Collections. Paper presented at Politics of Natural History, or: How to Decolonize the Natural History Museum, Berlin, Germany.
Drieënhuizen, C.A. ; Sysling, Fenneke. / Java Man and the Colonial Legacy of Fossil Collections. Paper presented at Politics of Natural History, or: How to Decolonize the Natural History Museum, Berlin, Germany.7 p.
@conference{27728293035d4ff79c02a2912be2f2e8,
title = "Java Man and the Colonial Legacy of Fossil Collections",
abstract = "This paper looks at human fossil collections in the Netherlands that were excavated in Dutch colonial Indonesia in 1891-92. The most famous specimen is what came to be called Java Man: the skullcap of a homo erectus. It was found on the island of Java by a team led by Dutch palaeontologist Eug{\`e}ne Dubois, who took his finds to the Netherlands where they ended up in the Natural History Museum in Leiden. Other notable finds of early hominids in the Dutch colonies include those excavated in the 1930s on Java by G.H.R. von Koenigswald.Java man is one of the highlights of the Natural History Museum in Leiden. Although in the Netherlands, like in other countries, cultural objects and physical anthropology collections have been the subject of debate in recent years, Java Man and the other human fossil collections (part of which are now in the Senckenberg Institute in Frankfurt, Germany) have not been part of these discussions.This is surprising given the fact that Java Man in particular is a single, well-known object and, as we show in this paper, the fossil collections have been claimed by Indonesia several times in the past. Already in 1951, Indonesia – independent for 2 years - first specified restitution claims which included collections of fossilized human skulls. For Indonesia, these fossils were important because they were useful in the new national narrative of the Indonesian state. They were proof that Indonesia was one of the oldest inhabited islands in the world and perhaps a cradle of mankind. The fossils referred to a pre-colonial past that could be read as something that all Indonesians shared.The exodus of the objects, according to Indonesian politician Mohammad Yamin, symbolized scientific imperialism and harmed Indonesia’s scientific interests. Around fifteen years after the first request, Indonesian scientists such as palaeontologist Teuku Jacob continued to call for the return of the paleontological collections. Only a few objects returned informally.With our focus on these objects’ provenance, their long contested political ownership and their representation in the Netherlands and in Indonesia, we emphasize that fossilized remains are sites of contested histories, identities and desire. We problematize histories of collecting and knowledge that emerged in Europe, to undo what Mignolo calls the coloniality of knowledge. We also suggest that Natural History Museums should be praised if they take the initiative to re-inscribe histories and perspectives in order to provide an active space for decolonial dialogues.",
author = "C.A. Drie{\"e}nhuizen and Fenneke Sysling",
year = "2018",
language = "English",
note = "Politics of Natural History, or: How to Decolonize the Natural History Museum ; Conference date: 06-09-2018 Through 07-09-2018",

}

Drieënhuizen, CA & Sysling, F 2018, 'Java Man and the Colonial Legacy of Fossil Collections' Paper presented at Politics of Natural History, or: How to Decolonize the Natural History Museum, Berlin, Germany, 6/09/18 - 7/09/18, .

Java Man and the Colonial Legacy of Fossil Collections. / Drieënhuizen, C.A.; Sysling, Fenneke.

2018. Paper presented at Politics of Natural History, or: How to Decolonize the Natural History Museum, Berlin, Germany.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperAcademic

TY - CONF

T1 - Java Man and the Colonial Legacy of Fossil Collections

AU - Drieënhuizen, C.A.

AU - Sysling, Fenneke

PY - 2018

Y1 - 2018

N2 - This paper looks at human fossil collections in the Netherlands that were excavated in Dutch colonial Indonesia in 1891-92. The most famous specimen is what came to be called Java Man: the skullcap of a homo erectus. It was found on the island of Java by a team led by Dutch palaeontologist Eugène Dubois, who took his finds to the Netherlands where they ended up in the Natural History Museum in Leiden. Other notable finds of early hominids in the Dutch colonies include those excavated in the 1930s on Java by G.H.R. von Koenigswald.Java man is one of the highlights of the Natural History Museum in Leiden. Although in the Netherlands, like in other countries, cultural objects and physical anthropology collections have been the subject of debate in recent years, Java Man and the other human fossil collections (part of which are now in the Senckenberg Institute in Frankfurt, Germany) have not been part of these discussions.This is surprising given the fact that Java Man in particular is a single, well-known object and, as we show in this paper, the fossil collections have been claimed by Indonesia several times in the past. Already in 1951, Indonesia – independent for 2 years - first specified restitution claims which included collections of fossilized human skulls. For Indonesia, these fossils were important because they were useful in the new national narrative of the Indonesian state. They were proof that Indonesia was one of the oldest inhabited islands in the world and perhaps a cradle of mankind. The fossils referred to a pre-colonial past that could be read as something that all Indonesians shared.The exodus of the objects, according to Indonesian politician Mohammad Yamin, symbolized scientific imperialism and harmed Indonesia’s scientific interests. Around fifteen years after the first request, Indonesian scientists such as palaeontologist Teuku Jacob continued to call for the return of the paleontological collections. Only a few objects returned informally.With our focus on these objects’ provenance, their long contested political ownership and their representation in the Netherlands and in Indonesia, we emphasize that fossilized remains are sites of contested histories, identities and desire. We problematize histories of collecting and knowledge that emerged in Europe, to undo what Mignolo calls the coloniality of knowledge. We also suggest that Natural History Museums should be praised if they take the initiative to re-inscribe histories and perspectives in order to provide an active space for decolonial dialogues.

AB - This paper looks at human fossil collections in the Netherlands that were excavated in Dutch colonial Indonesia in 1891-92. The most famous specimen is what came to be called Java Man: the skullcap of a homo erectus. It was found on the island of Java by a team led by Dutch palaeontologist Eugène Dubois, who took his finds to the Netherlands where they ended up in the Natural History Museum in Leiden. Other notable finds of early hominids in the Dutch colonies include those excavated in the 1930s on Java by G.H.R. von Koenigswald.Java man is one of the highlights of the Natural History Museum in Leiden. Although in the Netherlands, like in other countries, cultural objects and physical anthropology collections have been the subject of debate in recent years, Java Man and the other human fossil collections (part of which are now in the Senckenberg Institute in Frankfurt, Germany) have not been part of these discussions.This is surprising given the fact that Java Man in particular is a single, well-known object and, as we show in this paper, the fossil collections have been claimed by Indonesia several times in the past. Already in 1951, Indonesia – independent for 2 years - first specified restitution claims which included collections of fossilized human skulls. For Indonesia, these fossils were important because they were useful in the new national narrative of the Indonesian state. They were proof that Indonesia was one of the oldest inhabited islands in the world and perhaps a cradle of mankind. The fossils referred to a pre-colonial past that could be read as something that all Indonesians shared.The exodus of the objects, according to Indonesian politician Mohammad Yamin, symbolized scientific imperialism and harmed Indonesia’s scientific interests. Around fifteen years after the first request, Indonesian scientists such as palaeontologist Teuku Jacob continued to call for the return of the paleontological collections. Only a few objects returned informally.With our focus on these objects’ provenance, their long contested political ownership and their representation in the Netherlands and in Indonesia, we emphasize that fossilized remains are sites of contested histories, identities and desire. We problematize histories of collecting and knowledge that emerged in Europe, to undo what Mignolo calls the coloniality of knowledge. We also suggest that Natural History Museums should be praised if they take the initiative to re-inscribe histories and perspectives in order to provide an active space for decolonial dialogues.

M3 - Paper

ER -

Drieënhuizen CA, Sysling F. Java Man and the Colonial Legacy of Fossil Collections. 2018. Paper presented at Politics of Natural History, or: How to Decolonize the Natural History Museum, Berlin, Germany.