Tijdschrift voor Geschiedenis gedigitaliseerd, 1886-2008: Een verkenning van de inhoud als pleidooi voor het bijeenbrengen van digitale en traditionele onderzoeksmethoden

S.M. Hogervorst, Kees Ribbens

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

Abstract

After the digitization of all issues of the Dutch historical journal Tijdschrift voor Geschiedenis from 1886 till 2008, this article explores the content of this digital collection by applying two easily accessible digital methods: keyword search and word frequencies. It makes clear that interest in the nineteenth century has increased over time, while the seventeenth century has gradually become a less popular period in the Low Countries' historiography. Furthermore, the assumed post-WWII dominance of British and American historiography over German historiography cannot be confirmed unequivocally using these methods. The article also discusses to what extent traditional historical research may benefit from digital methods. The authors demonstrate the limitations of a 'deductive analysis' of a text corpus when using a set of keywords, as the translation of a concept into search terms is often arbitrary and incomplete. An 'inductive analysis' based on word frequency offers a more genuine and varied impression of a text corpus. The authors underline the importance of including digital methods in the regular toolkit of historians, and argue that working with digital tools challenges researchers and the way they conventionally handle their sources.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)309-325
JournalTijdschrift voor Geschiedenis
Volume131
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jun 2018

Fingerprint

Historiography
Key Words
Text Corpus
Word Frequency
Toolkit
Regular
Digitization
Second World War
Historian
Historical Research
Low Countries
Incomplete

Keywords

  • digital history, historiography,
  • digital history
  • DIRECTION
  • word frequencies
  • historiography
  • media analysis
  • history journals
  • textmining

Cite this

@article{bea25a6cf8fd404e8669ab4f28b6e7be,
title = "Tijdschrift voor Geschiedenis gedigitaliseerd, 1886-2008: Een verkenning van de inhoud als pleidooi voor het bijeenbrengen van digitale en traditionele onderzoeksmethoden",
abstract = "After the digitization of all issues of the Dutch historical journal Tijdschrift voor Geschiedenis from 1886 till 2008, this article explores the content of this digital collection by applying two easily accessible digital methods: keyword search and word frequencies. It makes clear that interest in the nineteenth century has increased over time, while the seventeenth century has gradually become a less popular period in the Low Countries' historiography. Furthermore, the assumed post-WWII dominance of British and American historiography over German historiography cannot be confirmed unequivocally using these methods. The article also discusses to what extent traditional historical research may benefit from digital methods. The authors demonstrate the limitations of a 'deductive analysis' of a text corpus when using a set of keywords, as the translation of a concept into search terms is often arbitrary and incomplete. An 'inductive analysis' based on word frequency offers a more genuine and varied impression of a text corpus. The authors underline the importance of including digital methods in the regular toolkit of historians, and argue that working with digital tools challenges researchers and the way they conventionally handle their sources.",
keywords = "digital history, historiography,, digital history, DIRECTION, word frequencies, historiography, media analysis, history journals, textmining",
author = "S.M. Hogervorst and Kees Ribbens",
year = "2018",
month = "6",
doi = "10.5117/TVGESCH2018.2.HOGE",
language = "English",
volume = "131",
pages = "309--325",
journal = "Tijdschrift voor Geschiedenis",
issn = "0040-7518",
publisher = "Wolters-Noordhoff B.V.",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Tijdschrift voor Geschiedenis gedigitaliseerd, 1886-2008

T2 - Een verkenning van de inhoud als pleidooi voor het bijeenbrengen van digitale en traditionele onderzoeksmethoden

AU - Hogervorst, S.M.

AU - Ribbens, Kees

PY - 2018/6

Y1 - 2018/6

N2 - After the digitization of all issues of the Dutch historical journal Tijdschrift voor Geschiedenis from 1886 till 2008, this article explores the content of this digital collection by applying two easily accessible digital methods: keyword search and word frequencies. It makes clear that interest in the nineteenth century has increased over time, while the seventeenth century has gradually become a less popular period in the Low Countries' historiography. Furthermore, the assumed post-WWII dominance of British and American historiography over German historiography cannot be confirmed unequivocally using these methods. The article also discusses to what extent traditional historical research may benefit from digital methods. The authors demonstrate the limitations of a 'deductive analysis' of a text corpus when using a set of keywords, as the translation of a concept into search terms is often arbitrary and incomplete. An 'inductive analysis' based on word frequency offers a more genuine and varied impression of a text corpus. The authors underline the importance of including digital methods in the regular toolkit of historians, and argue that working with digital tools challenges researchers and the way they conventionally handle their sources.

AB - After the digitization of all issues of the Dutch historical journal Tijdschrift voor Geschiedenis from 1886 till 2008, this article explores the content of this digital collection by applying two easily accessible digital methods: keyword search and word frequencies. It makes clear that interest in the nineteenth century has increased over time, while the seventeenth century has gradually become a less popular period in the Low Countries' historiography. Furthermore, the assumed post-WWII dominance of British and American historiography over German historiography cannot be confirmed unequivocally using these methods. The article also discusses to what extent traditional historical research may benefit from digital methods. The authors demonstrate the limitations of a 'deductive analysis' of a text corpus when using a set of keywords, as the translation of a concept into search terms is often arbitrary and incomplete. An 'inductive analysis' based on word frequency offers a more genuine and varied impression of a text corpus. The authors underline the importance of including digital methods in the regular toolkit of historians, and argue that working with digital tools challenges researchers and the way they conventionally handle their sources.

KW - digital history, historiography,

KW - digital history

KW - DIRECTION

KW - word frequencies

KW - historiography

KW - media analysis

KW - history journals

KW - textmining

U2 - 10.5117/TVGESCH2018.2.HOGE

DO - 10.5117/TVGESCH2018.2.HOGE

M3 - Article

VL - 131

SP - 309

EP - 325

JO - Tijdschrift voor Geschiedenis

JF - Tijdschrift voor Geschiedenis

SN - 0040-7518

IS - 2

ER -