Walking the tightrope with an e-portfolio

imbalance between support and autonomy hampers self-directed learning

J. Beckers, Diana Dolmans, Michelle M.H. Knapen, Jeroen Van Merriënboer

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

Abstract

Teacher coaching is essential to support self-directed learning, but requires a lot of time and energy. This mixed-methods study investigated the effects of using an e-portfolio with a self-coaching protocol and limited teacher coaching on the development of self-directed learning skills and motivation. With regard to self-directed learning, students’ overestimation of performance on learning tasks grew over time, while their ability to formulate points for improvement did not change significantly. With regard to motivation, students’ controlled (i.e. largely extrinsic) motivation increased while their autonomous (i.e. largely intrinsic) motivation decreased. Thematic analysis of interviews demonstrated students needed more support and feedback from their teacher. The use of suboptimal cues for performance assessment and an imperfect balance between autonomy and support hampered self-directed learning and motivation. We recommend providing just-in-time feedback about performance on learning tasks and giving students some autonomy over the choice of learning tasks, to enhance reflection and motivation.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)260-288
Number of pages29
JournalJournal of Vocational Education & Training
Volume71
Issue number2
Early online date2 Aug 2018
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 3 Apr 2019

Fingerprint

autonomy
coaching
learning
teacher
student
extrinsic motivation
intrinsic motivation
performance assessment
performance
energy
ability
interview
time

Keywords

  • Learning theory
  • competence
  • curriculum innovation
  • vocational education & training
  • VET and development
  • TASK SELECTION
  • UNDERGRADUATE
  • MOTIVATION
  • EDUCATION
  • STUDENTS
  • WELL
  • FEEDBACK
  • QUALITY
  • SKILLS

Cite this

Beckers, J. ; Dolmans, Diana ; Knapen, Michelle M.H. ; Van Merriënboer, Jeroen. / Walking the tightrope with an e-portfolio : imbalance between support and autonomy hampers self-directed learning. In: Journal of Vocational Education & Training. 2019 ; Vol. 71, No. 2. pp. 260-288.
@article{85b7f69d61b44d2ab5cce4d4950ee8db,
title = "Walking the tightrope with an e-portfolio: imbalance between support and autonomy hampers self-directed learning",
abstract = "Teacher coaching is essential to support self-directed learning, but requires a lot of time and energy. This mixed-methods study investigated the effects of using an e-portfolio with a self-coaching protocol and limited teacher coaching on the development of self-directed learning skills and motivation. With regard to self-directed learning, students’ overestimation of performance on learning tasks grew over time, while their ability to formulate points for improvement did not change significantly. With regard to motivation, students’ controlled (i.e. largely extrinsic) motivation increased while their autonomous (i.e. largely intrinsic) motivation decreased. Thematic analysis of interviews demonstrated students needed more support and feedback from their teacher. The use of suboptimal cues for performance assessment and an imperfect balance between autonomy and support hampered self-directed learning and motivation. We recommend providing just-in-time feedback about performance on learning tasks and giving students some autonomy over the choice of learning tasks, to enhance reflection and motivation.",
keywords = "Learning theory, competence, curriculum innovation, vocational education & training, VET and development, TASK SELECTION, UNDERGRADUATE, MOTIVATION, EDUCATION, STUDENTS, WELL, FEEDBACK, QUALITY, SKILLS",
author = "J. Beckers and Diana Dolmans and Knapen, {Michelle M.H.} and {Van Merri{\"e}nboer}, Jeroen",
year = "2019",
month = "4",
day = "3",
doi = "10.1080/13636820.2018.1481448",
language = "English",
volume = "71",
pages = "260--288",
journal = "Journal of Vocational Education & Training",
issn = "1363-6820",
publisher = "Routledge",
number = "2",

}

Walking the tightrope with an e-portfolio : imbalance between support and autonomy hampers self-directed learning. / Beckers, J.; Dolmans, Diana; Knapen, Michelle M.H.; Van Merriënboer, Jeroen.

In: Journal of Vocational Education & Training, Vol. 71, No. 2, 03.04.2019, p. 260-288.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Walking the tightrope with an e-portfolio

T2 - imbalance between support and autonomy hampers self-directed learning

AU - Beckers, J.

AU - Dolmans, Diana

AU - Knapen, Michelle M.H.

AU - Van Merriënboer, Jeroen

PY - 2019/4/3

Y1 - 2019/4/3

N2 - Teacher coaching is essential to support self-directed learning, but requires a lot of time and energy. This mixed-methods study investigated the effects of using an e-portfolio with a self-coaching protocol and limited teacher coaching on the development of self-directed learning skills and motivation. With regard to self-directed learning, students’ overestimation of performance on learning tasks grew over time, while their ability to formulate points for improvement did not change significantly. With regard to motivation, students’ controlled (i.e. largely extrinsic) motivation increased while their autonomous (i.e. largely intrinsic) motivation decreased. Thematic analysis of interviews demonstrated students needed more support and feedback from their teacher. The use of suboptimal cues for performance assessment and an imperfect balance between autonomy and support hampered self-directed learning and motivation. We recommend providing just-in-time feedback about performance on learning tasks and giving students some autonomy over the choice of learning tasks, to enhance reflection and motivation.

AB - Teacher coaching is essential to support self-directed learning, but requires a lot of time and energy. This mixed-methods study investigated the effects of using an e-portfolio with a self-coaching protocol and limited teacher coaching on the development of self-directed learning skills and motivation. With regard to self-directed learning, students’ overestimation of performance on learning tasks grew over time, while their ability to formulate points for improvement did not change significantly. With regard to motivation, students’ controlled (i.e. largely extrinsic) motivation increased while their autonomous (i.e. largely intrinsic) motivation decreased. Thematic analysis of interviews demonstrated students needed more support and feedback from their teacher. The use of suboptimal cues for performance assessment and an imperfect balance between autonomy and support hampered self-directed learning and motivation. We recommend providing just-in-time feedback about performance on learning tasks and giving students some autonomy over the choice of learning tasks, to enhance reflection and motivation.

KW - Learning theory

KW - competence

KW - curriculum innovation

KW - vocational education & training

KW - VET and development

KW - TASK SELECTION

KW - UNDERGRADUATE

KW - MOTIVATION

KW - EDUCATION

KW - STUDENTS

KW - WELL

KW - FEEDBACK

KW - QUALITY

KW - SKILLS

U2 - 10.1080/13636820.2018.1481448

DO - 10.1080/13636820.2018.1481448

M3 - Article

VL - 71

SP - 260

EP - 288

JO - Journal of Vocational Education & Training

JF - Journal of Vocational Education & Training

SN - 1363-6820

IS - 2

ER -